en English af Afrikaans sq Albanian ar Arabic hy Armenian az Azerbaijani eu Basque be Belarusian bg Bulgarian ca Catalan zh-CN Chinese (Simplified) zh-TW Chinese (Traditional) hr Croatian cs Czech da Danish nl Dutch et Estonian tl Filipino fi Finnish fr French gl Galician ka Georgian de German el Greek ht Haitian Creole iw Hebrew hi Hindi hu Hungarian is Icelandic id Indonesian ga Irish it Italian ja Japanese ko Korean lv Latvian lt Lithuanian mk Macedonian ms Malay mt Maltese no Norwegian fa Persian pl Polish pt Portuguese ro Romanian ru Russian sr Serbian sk Slovak sl Slovenian es Spanish sw Swahili sv Swedish th Thai tr Turkish uk Ukrainian ur Urdu vi Vietnamese cy Welsh yi Yiddish
Open Translation

GENEVA: Virginia Comolli is the research manager for the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime (GI-TOC) and author of a new report: ‘Plastic for Profit - Tracing Illicit Plastic Waste Flows, Supply Chains and Actors’.

Before joining GI-TOC she was head of the Conflict, Security and Development programme at the International Institute for Strategic Studies.

Her report highlights how companies and criminal groups are involved in an array of criminal behaviour aimed at circumventing export laws that control the movement and treatment of hazardous waste to developing countries.

Comolli says the US$50 billion waste business also provides cover for money laundering, tax evasion, human and drug trafficking via unscrupulous or unwitting logistics providers:

On October 31, world leaders convened in Glasgow as the United Kingdom host[ed] the 26th UN Climate Change Conference of the Parties (COP26). To achieve a Net-Zero future, it is essential – among other interventions – to manage and control the indiscriminate use of plastic and the way it is disposed of once it becomes waste.

Confronting the trade in plastic waste is also an issue of climate justice, as the by-products aggravate health and environmental harms in lower-income countries and among communities that lack the political leverage to reject this waste.

Owing to its durability and affordability, plastic has become the material of choice for an endless list of purposes. This has led to its overuse and the subsequent, very serious, questions around how plastic is disposed of. It is a bleak statistic that less than 20 percent of plastic is recycled globally. As for the remainder, the solution for the key waste-producing countries of Europe and North America, which are the major culprits and which have inadequate recycling capacity, has long been to ship waste abroad, especially to developing countries in Asia and Africa.

It is a ‘solution’ that is unsustainable, for we are witnessing a convergence of factors that would strongly suggest that current rates of plastic consumption are only likely to worsen over the coming decades.

Among others, a strong economic argument hinders change. Producing virgin plastic is often more affordable than manufacturing with its recycled equivalent, a reality that is very much fuelled by the shale gas boom in the US and the way it is encouraging fracking internationally.

Therefore, the global waste plastics recycling market is going to struggle to be competitive in the face of cheaper and often better-quality raw plastic.

The Basel Convention, and other related legislation, is designed to safeguard receiving countries that do not have sophisticated plastic processing facilities from becoming dumping grounds for foreign waste.

But despite the Convention, the economic imperative of the highly lucrative recycled plastics market - expected to reach US$50.36 billion by 2022 - has attracted the attention of organized criminals and legitimate businesses that engage in fraudulent practices to circumvent the Convention and associated legislation. Misdeclaration and concealment of hazardous and mixed waste, money laundering, financial crime and corruption are among the crimes committed in relation to plastic waste.

The criminalized supply chain for plastic waste often involves complex networks of brokers, recycling companies, logistics and shipping entities, as well corrupt officials - often at ports - who arrange the shipping of hazardous and mixed waste from countries such as the United States, the UK or The Netherlands to Malaysia, the Philippines and other countries predominantly in the Global South. In recipient countries, consignments are illegally disposed of in the absence of suitable processing facilities.

But the problem goes beyond just white-collar crime. Firstly, there is evidence in the illicit plastic waste economy of convergence with other criminal activities carried out by polycriminal groups in places such as Turkey and the UK, for instance, which also deal in drugs and prostitution. In some cases, waste-recycling companies have been accused of involvement in human trafficking and modern slavery as a way of sourcing cheap labour.

And arguably even more concerning is the long-term impact of inappropriate disposal practices on the environment and the health of the local communities who bear the brunt of the consequences.

The most acute effects are borne by those living in vulnerable regions of Asia and Africa, the main recipients of hazardous foreign waste, who have to contend on a daily basis with the pollution and contamination resulting from it.

The health and environmental harm caused by the illegal dumping and burning of plastic waste in countries such as Indonesia or Malaysia, for example, is enormous. Once released into the environment, plastics - and the fumes generated through their incineration - pollute soil, water and air, poison food production and are the cause of a myriad of severe health conditions.

As discussions around ‘ecocide’ and its possible inclusion among the crimes prosecuted by the International Criminal Court become more prominent, the need to draw attention to the detrimental impact of the illegal transnational waste trade could not be more timely.

Given the upward trajectory of illegality in the plastic waste trade, the exponential growth in plastic production and likely long-term reliance on raw (as opposed to recycled) plastic, and the continual proliferation of illicit trade routes, a multi-pronged approach is needed to encourage a rethink of the current waste disposal model.

To be effective, all actors across jurisdictions and sectors ought to be included, from industry (i.e. plastics producers, recycling companies, brokering and logistics supply) to governments and regulators, from law enforcement to NGOs.

Communities on the ground who are most affected must also be included as agents of change. This, in turn, would help emerging and developing economies achieve environmental justice – a goal that currently looks out of reach for many.

COP26 embodie[d] the need for a joint global effort to mitigate the climate crisis and will encourage us to set goals that meet the challenges we face today. Policy across sectors should then be guided by our responsibility to work towards these goals.

The ultimate objective should be to replace plastic with better products and dramatically ramp up the ability to affordably and safely recycle plastic that exists. But in the meantime, there is a critical need now to address the waste generated by plastic by tackling those actors that are involved illicitly in exploiting the trade in waste plastic, and to fundamentally revise the factors that are enabling those actors to exploit this industry.

GI-TOC is an independent civil-society organization, headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland, with a globally dispersed secretariat and a high-level advisory board. Members include prominent law-enforcement, governance and development practitioners dedicated to seeking new and innovative strategies and responses to organized crime.
Story Type: Comment

Vote for my Story

Our Rating: 9% - 1 votes

1000 Characters left

Latest News

November 24, 2021
People Editor

Logistics specialist wins a couple of Green Apples

HEATHROW: B&H Worldwide, specialising in aerospace logistics, has won two environment awards from the NGO Green Apple Organisation for its carbon reduction initiatives. B&H was recognised for cutting its carbon footprint over the past two years covering the…
November 24, 2021
Biodiversity Editor

TotalEnergies to pay Suriname US$50 million for oil field offset

NIJMEGEN, The Netherlands: BankTrack is the tracking, campaigning and NGO support organisation targeting the operations and investments of commercial banks globally. Maaike Beenes, its Climate Team coordinator, says as rich countries fail to deliver on their…
November 23, 2021
Technology Editor

Maiden voyage of fertilizer-carrying electric containership

OSLO: Norwegian fertilizer producer Yara International has completed the maiden voyage of its first electric-powered container ship Yara Birkeland as part of a two-year, NOK133.5 million programme to certify it as an autonomous vessel. Yara has also begun the…
November 23, 2021
Emissions Editor

COP26: one small step or giant leap for mankind?

LONDON: Simon Retallack, director for Latin America at the Carbon Trust, says despite not agreeing to reduce global warming to less than a catastrophic +2.4 Celsius, delegates at the COP26 summit at least decided the following: " • Most of the world is now…
November 22, 2021
People Editor

Climate crisis means it is time to be predictive not reactive

MUJUGA, RWANDA: In an appeal for money to feed 811 million people worldwide, a statement from the UN’s logistics aid agency World Food Programme (WFP) says COP26 fell far short of the groundbreaking success many had hoped for: “ It is critical for the world…
November 19, 2021
Technology Editor

Transparency key for carbon calculators

ENGELBERG, CH: Peter Somaglia is a logistics executive and co-founder of the Swiss-based emissions calculator service CarbonCare. Despite the increasing use of sustainable aviation fuel (SAF), lightweight ULDs, digital airwaybills, carbon offset programmes…
November 19, 2021
Manufacturing Editor

CMA CGM orders emissions-reducing A350 freighters

TOULOUSE: CMA CGM Group has signed an MoU with Airbus for four A350 freighters, adding to a fleet of five A330-200Fs operated by its air cargo division. The A350F is based on the A350-1000 passenger aircraft with 70 percent made from composite materials. The…
November 19, 2021
Transportation Editor

Maersk issues bond for building methane-powered ships

COPENHAGEN: A.P. Moller – Maersk has issued a 10-year, €500 million ‘green bond’ to fund the build of its first feeder vessel plus eight large container vessels capable of operating on carbon neutral methanol by 2023 and 2024, respectively. The transaction,…
November 18, 2021
Circular Economy Editor

Europe targets illegal waste shipments

BRUSSELS: The European Commission has announced stricter controls on the export of waste from the EU. The top five EU export waste markets last year were Turkey (13.7 million tonnes); India (2.7 million); UK (1.8 million); Switzerland (1.6 million); and…
November 17, 2021
Emissions Editor

What’s the fifth largest carbon emitter in the world?

STANFORD, CA: John Ribeiro-Broomhead is a recent graduate of Stanford University’s Master’s programme in Atmosphere and Energy Sciences. He notes the recent COP26 climate focus on energy, transportation and the environment overlooked the one word that…
November 16, 2021
Technology Editor

Tevva electric truck launch gets US$57 million charge

LONDON/BATILLY, France: Electric and hydrogen truck developer Tevva has raised an additional US$57 million from new and existing investors to establish a new manufacturing facility. The company has now raised a total of US$70 million over the past 12 months…
November 16, 2021
Circular Economy Editor

LafargeHolcim to reuse coal ash waste as cement

STE. GENEVIEVE, MS: LafargeHolcim has received its first barge shipment of 2,000 tons of coal ash from CenterPoint Energy’s coal-fired Indiana powerplant for recycling into cement. Together with waste management provider Geocycle, the three companies plan to…

We are using cookies

By continuing you are agreeing to our use of cookies

I understand